Leaf and Stick Insect Variation | The Institute for Creation Research


Leaf and Stick Insect Variation

The phylum Arthropoda suddenly appears in the fossil record in a most un-Darwinian way.1 The largest group within the arthropods is the class Insecta—the insects. There is no fossil evidence depicting how insects supposedly came from non-insects. Entomologists can only suggest or estimate they originated many millions of years ago.2 ICR’s Dr. Jeff Tomkins addresses this evolutionary problem known as the hexapod gap. Hexapods are the insects and springtails.

Insects first appear about 385 million years ago, according to evolutionary dating. The earliest known insect, which appeared suddenly without any insect precursors, was a wingless creature that looked much like a modern silverfish. But after this initial appearance, there was allegedly an absence of insects in the sedimentary rocks for the next 60 million years. There was no sign of a single roach, grasshopper, or dragonfly. This huge evolutionary gap between 385 million and 325 [supposed] million years ago is known among paleontologists as the hexapod gap.3

In other words, insects have always been insects. This includes the fascinating leaf and stick insects called the phasmids. Scientists writing in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences give recognition not to the Creator but to natural selection for phasmid innovation.4 They wrote, “Phasmids (stick and leaf insects) exemplify the extraordinary power of natural selection to shape organismal phenotypes.”5 A recent article in Phys.org, a science website, stated that “regardless of type, those insects that express a protective stick- or leaf-like appearance all evolved the same basic body parts.”6

Creationists would disagree. Entomologists have never observed the alleged evolution of these same basic body parts. Instead, the insects were created with the basic stick- or leaf-like appearances that are found in the fossil record and today. With such design features, the insects can move in and fill various niches, which is described by the continuous environmental tracking (CET) model.7 In other words, since nature has never shown it has an extraordinary power to shape organisms, it stands to reason that a Creator who exists beyond nature actually wielded this astonishing control.

The Phys.org article also stated,

Something else the team learned was that because the same body parts kept evolving in different insects, they could predict how some modern insects will evolve. The key was looking at the environmental factors that led to changes that had already occurred. Creatures that live in similar environments, they note, tend to evolve in similar ways, including their means of camouflage.6

The evolutionists exhibit their faith in selection for detailed morphological changes in these insects. We do see minor changes of the same body parts occur, and this is predicted by CET. This is because phasmids—like all insects—are “active, problem-solving creatures that continuously track environmental changes to better fit existing niches or fill new ones.”7

And speaking of camouflage, how did the remarkable phasmidian camouflage evolve? Scientists at the University of Gottingen don’t know.

The age estimation of the phylogenetic tree suggests that most of the old lineages emerged after the dinosaurs became extinct 66 million years ago. Thus, the remarkable camouflage of stick and leaf insects most probably evolved afterwards as adaptation against predatory mammals and birds.8

Boisseau et al. appeal to the unscientific philosophy of convergent evolution to explain the evolution of the 20 basic body features.5,9,10 Science writer Yirka states in Phys.org,

Prior evidence has shown that similar physical characteristics can evolve in unrelated creatures, a process called convergent evolution. For this new study, the researchers looked at two specific types of insects to learn more about how convergence works. They discovered that stick- and leaf-imitating insects had all evolved the same 20 basic body features, including body shape, head shape and lobster-like features. In all cases, they noted, the features had evolved to help the insects blend into the background to avoid being eaten by predators.6

Saying the stick- and leaf-imitating insects “all evolved the same 20 basic body features” is not a scientific explanation. There are similar physical characteristics found in these two unrelated animals, so they can blend into the environment. But there is no indication as to “how convergence works” or if convergence worked.

Insects were incredibly diverse and complex from the beginning. They have been designed with the ability to undergo limited variation in their basic body plan as they move in and fill ecological niches.

References

  1. Clarey, T. Cambrian Explosion Alive and Well. Creation Science Update. Posted on ICR.org January 14, 2021.
  2. Thomas, B. Rare Insect Evolved at the Wrong Time. Creation Science Update. Posted on ICR.org December 30, 2008.
  3. Tomkins, J. P. 2018. Evolutionist Can’t Fill the Hexapod Gap. Acts & Facts. 47 (8): 14.
  4. Guliuzza, R. 2010. Natural Selection is Not ‘Nature’s Design Process.’ Acts & Facts. 39 (4): 10–11.
  5. Boisseau, R. et al. 2024. Divergence Time and Environmental Similarity Predict the Strength of Morphological Convergence in Stick and Leaf Insects. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. 122 (1): e2319485121.
  6. Yirka, B. Convergent Evolution: Stick and Leaf Insects Share 20 Body Features. Phys.org. Posted on phys.org December 27, 2024.
  7. Guliuzza, R. and P. Gaskill. Continuous Environmental Tracking: An Engineering Framework to Understand Adaptation and Diversification. Proceedings of the International Conference on Creationism. 8, article 11: 158–184.
  8. University of Gottingen. Was Early Stick Insect Evolution Triggered by Birds and Mammals? EurekAlert! Posted on eurekaalert.org October 7, 2019. Emphasis added.
  9. Guliuzza, R. 2017. Major Evolutionary Blunders: Convergent Evolution Is a Seductive Intellectual Swindle. Acts & Facts. 46 (3): 17–19.
  10. Bethell, T. 2017. Chapter 10. In Darwin’s House of Cards. Seattle, WA: Discovery Institute Press.

* Dr. Sherwin is a news writer at the Institute for Creation Research. He earned an M.A. in invertebrate zoology from the University of Northern Colorado and received an honorary doctorate of science from Pensacola Christian College.

The Latest
DAYS OF PRAISE DEVOTIONALS
Winter 2026
...

NEWS
Your Brain Counts Before You Do
Flash three dots on a screen for a split second, and most people can tell how many appeared without counting. Show 20 dots, and the answer becomes less...

NEWS
The Christian’s Higher Duty
“To the distinguished Character of Patriot, it should be our highest Glory to add the more distinguished Character of Christian.”1...

ACTS & FACTS
ICR 2026 Resource Catalog
At the Institute for Creation Research, our mission is not only to conduct research demonstrating how science confirms Scripture but also to share this...

NEWS
Watching PBS: An Imaginary (Evolutionary) Elephant Walk
by Jake Hebert, Ph.D., and Michael J. Boyle, Ph.D.* “Make believe” are the first two words in the lyrics of Henry Mancini’s 1961...

NEWS
Engineers Learn from Octopus Arms
An octopus can do something engineers still struggle to copy: control eight soft arms with no bones or fixed joints. Each arm can bend, twist, stretch,...

CREATION PODCAST
World-Class PhD Chemist: THIS Is Why I Believe in God
Why does this world-class chemist say the evidence for a Creator is undeniable? Mary Clair Kelly sits down with Dr. Marcos Eberlin to talk about his career...

CREATION PODCAST
Christian Scientist: Everyone Needs to Know About These Fossil...
Scientists just found blood vessels and proteins preserved inside dinosaur bone — soft tissue that simply could not have survived for millions of years....

CREATION PODCAST
Christian Engineer: These Remarkable Organisms Will Make You...
Today, Trey sits down with Dr. Randy Guliuzza, expert in engineered biology, and discusses the remarkable abilities we see in living things and that organisms’...

CREATION PODCAST
Christian PhD: They Do NOT Want You Knowing about These Discoveries
Scientists keep finding soft tissue, blood cells, and even stretchy proteins inside dinosaur bones — things that should have turned to dust millions...