Whale Study Confirms Evolutionary Trees Don't Work | The Institute for Creation Research

Whale Study Confirms Evolutionary Trees Don't Work

"Phylogenies," or evolutionary trees, are diagrams that illustrate how certain plants or animals supposedly evolved and branched out from common ancestors. Charles Darwin drew one, usually referred to as his "tree of life," in one of his notebooks. Scientists since then have compiled thousands of phylogenies, but they continue to conflict with one another, presenting a confused and contradictory picture of evolutionary history.

Authors of a recent study published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences noted that most evolutionary trees do not show extinctions, but instead depict an ever-increasing diversification of species over time. However, the fossil record does show extinctions, and the study authors wrote that this inconsistency "is puzzling, and it casts serious doubt on phylogenetic techniques [using evolutionary trees] for inferring the history of species diversity."1

This admission should signal the fundamentally flawed nature of Darwinian evolution's premise that complex life evolved from simpler forms. Are the countless published phylogenies all to be distrusted? Other evolutionists have thought so, since "an onslaught of negative evidence" consistently plagues the whole tree-building enterprise.2

Since patterns drawn from evolutionary trees contradict patterns drawn from the fossil record, the scientists of this particular PNAS report proposed a new method of building evolutionary trees that they thought might fix this problem. They factored into their phylogeny-building equations rapid evolution, slow evolution, no evolution (called "stasis"), and even reverse evolution (extinctions). This should supposedly help build more historically accurate phylogenies in cases where groups of animals or plants "lack a reliable fossil record."1

The researchers attempted to demonstrate their new technique by applying it to cetaceans, an order of swimming mammals that includes whales and dolphins. They formed phylogenies for five "primary cetacean groups" and then averaged the results to depict the total number of species over evolutionary time.1 But why couldn't they just have analyzed all cetaceans at once? In the end, their analysis appeared to manipulate the data until they very loosely fit the cetacean fossil record.

Both the cetacean fossil "history" and phylogeny used in the PNAS study were built on evolutionary assumptions. That circular reasoning was far removed from the actual data and hardly represents an objective approach. Despite its effort to rescue the use of evolutionary trees in tracing evolutionary histories, this report merely succeeded in emphasizing their consistent failure to match even evolutionary interpretations of the fossil record.

Since the fossil record does not contain any hints of molecules-to-man evolution, it makes sense that evolutionary trees continually conflict with it. Fossils instead show that creatures were created as distinct life forms from the beginning.3

References

  1. Morlon, H., T. L. Parsons, and J. B. Plotkin. Reconciling molecular phylogenies with the fossil record. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. Published online before print September 19, 2011.
  2. Lawton, G. 2009. Why Darwin Was Wrong About the Tree of Life. New Scientist. 2692: 34-39.
  3. Gish, D. 2006. Evolution: The Fossil Record Still Says, No! El Cajon, CA: Institute for Creation Research.

* Mr. Thomas is Science Writer at the Institute for Creation Research.

Article posted on September 30, 2011.

The Latest
NEWS
Brain Awareness at Death: Beyond the Physical
Death is often pictured as an instant shutdown. The heart stops, blood flow fails, and the brain quiets. But recordings from dying brains suggest the...

NEWS
Watching PBS: Sexually Confused . . . in More Ways Than One
The origin of sex is one of the most obvious difficulties with the evolutionary story. Male reproductive organs are useless without corresponding female...

DAYS OF PRAISE DEVOTIONALS
Winter 2026
...

NEWS
Your Brain Counts Before You Do
Flash three dots on a screen for a split second, and most people can tell how many appeared without counting. Show 20 dots, and the answer becomes less...

NEWS
The Christian’s Higher Duty
“To the distinguished Character of Patriot, it should be our highest Glory to add the more distinguished Character of Christian.”1...

ACTS & FACTS
ICR 2026 Resource Catalog
At the Institute for Creation Research, our mission is not only to conduct research demonstrating how science confirms Scripture but also to share this...

NEWS
Watching PBS: An Imaginary (Evolutionary) Elephant Walk
by Jake Hebert, Ph.D., and Michael J. Boyle, Ph.D.* “Make believe” are the first two words in the lyrics of Henry Mancini’s 1961...

NEWS
Engineers Learn from Octopus Arms
An octopus can do something engineers still struggle to copy: control eight soft arms with no bones or fixed joints. Each arm can bend, twist, stretch,...

CREATION PODCAST
World-Class PhD Chemist: THIS Is Why I Believe in God
Why does this world-class chemist say the evidence for a Creator is undeniable? Mary Clair Kelly sits down with Dr. Marcos Eberlin to talk about his career...

CREATION PODCAST
Christian Scientist: Everyone Needs to Know About These Fossil...
Scientists just found blood vessels and proteins preserved inside dinosaur bone — soft tissue that simply could not have survived for millions of years....