Human-Chimp Genetic Similarity: Do Shared 'Mistakes' Prove Common Ancestry? | The Institute for Creation Research

 
Human-Chimp Genetic Similarity: Do Shared 'Mistakes' Prove Common Ancestry?

The ICR life sciences team continues to tackle the problem of refuting the evolutionary tree of life1 and, specifically, the frequently cited claim that humans and chimpanzees have an unusually high degree of genetic similarity and that this is due to common ancestry.2 This claim of shared DNA spans several levels of DNA comparisons and often receives strength from compelling analogies. In previous columns, we discussed DNA similarity at the level of chromosomal identity and of DNA sequence identity,2-4 and of the analogy made by evolutionists to human genetic testing.5 In this column, we discuss DNA similarity at the level of shared mutations and the analogy to literary plagiarism.

DNA is a well-designed blueprint containing the instructions for the anatomy and physiology of nearly every species, including humans. Its function and operation are extremely complex and well-regulated; not surprisingly, it is copied and transmitted from cell to cell in a very fastidious manner. However, on occasion, random changes…"mutations"… are introduced, and if mutations happen to land in a part of the DNA that codes for protein (i.e., in a "gene"), the consequences can be striking…for example, sickle cell anemia, which is due to a mutation in the globin gene. Despite these occasional changes, the entirety of the human blueprint ("genome") has been transmitted largely intact from parent to progeny throughout human history.

If mutations occur in the reproductive cells ("gametes"), these errors can be transmitted through many generations. Because they are rare, random, and seldom reversible, mutations serve as a useful marker of ancestry. Evolutionists have capitalized on this fact and have used it to claim that shared mutations between humans and chimps prove common ancestry between these two creatures.

This evolutionary claim is strengthened by analogy to literary plagiarism. For example, imagine that a popular author happens upon a near-duplicate of his best-selling work. To prove that the second book is a fraud and not original, the author might point out identical sentences or paragraphs between the two works. To strengthen his case, he might also look for shared mistakes between the two volumes, since the chance that both authors would make the same random typo in the same paragraph is very low. By analogy, evolutionists claim that humans and chimpanzees share an unusually high number of shared mutations in the same DNA locations and that the only explanation for this similarity is plagiarism of these genomes from a common ancestor.

Is there another explanation for this phenomenon?

Just like the appeal to human genetic testing,5 the analogy to literary plagiarism relies on a hidden…but critical…assumption: The ability to spot shared mistakes assumes knowledge of the language used. Hence, the claim that humans and chimps share DNA mistakes assumes that scientists speak the "language" of DNA well enough to identify errors reliably.

Is this assumption true?

The shared "mistakes" between the two genomes are most often found in the region of the genome previously labeled "junk." Evidence has been accumulating that "junk" DNA is, in fact, functional.6 These data clearly indicate that the assumption behind the evolution claim is false…we do not speak the language of the genome well enough to reliably separate shared "mistakes" from common design features. Hence, the claim that shared "mistakes" prove common ancestry is invalid.

The research team is continuing to investigate the true genetic identity between chimps and humans. Expect to read more about what we discover in upcoming issues!

References

  1. Jeanson, N. 2010. New Frontiers in Animal Classification. Acts & Facts. 39 (5): 6.
  2. Jeanson, N. and J. Tomkins. 2011. Human-Chimp Genetic Similarity: Is the Evolutionary Dogma Valid? Acts & Facts. 40 (7): 6.
  3. Tomkins, J. 2011. New Human-Chimp Chromosome 2 Data Challenge Common Ancestry Claims. Acts & Facts. 40 (5): 6.
  4. Tomkins, J. 2011. New Research Undermines Key Argument for Human Evolution. Acts & Facts. 40 (6): 6.
  5. Jeanson, N. 2011. Human-Chimp Genetic Similarity: Refuting the Appeal to Human Genetic Testing. Acts & Facts. 40 (8): 8.
  6. Wells, J. 2011. The Myth of Junk DNA. Seattle, WA: Discovery Institute Press.

* Dr. Jeanson is Research Associate at the Institute for Creation Research and received his Ph.D. in Cell and Developmental Biology from Harvard University.

 Cite this article: Jeanson, N. 2011. Human-Chimp Genetic Similarity: Do Shared "Mistakes" Prove Common Ancestry? Acts & Facts. 40 (9): 6.

The Latest
CREATION.LIVE PODCAST
Searching for Truth Across the Globe | Creation.Live Podcast:...
How can we bring the Gospel of Jesus Christ and the truth of creation to others outside our small spheres of influence?   Host...

NEWS
Marine Mammals: Designed for Deep Diving
While you’re reading this, hold your breath. What is now happening is your blood is delivering the last of oxygenated blood cells to your tissues...

CREATION PODCAST
Humanity's Demise at the Hands of Genetic Entropy | The Creation...
Welcome to the fourth episode in a series called “The Failures of Old Earth Creationism.” Many Christians attempt to fit old earth...

NEWS
''Inside-Out'' Fossil is Amazingly Preserved
It is widely known that vast numbers of fossils—vertebrate and invertebrate—have been discovered incredibly well-preserved.1,2...

NEWS
The Resurrection and the Origin of Life
At Easter time we focus on the cardinal Christian doctrine of the Resurrection. Without the Resurrection, Christianity is a sham. The truth that Jesus...

NEWS
Is an Ancient Extinct Tree-Dweller Our Relative?
Human evolution has always been hazy with seemingly as many attempted explanations for how we evolved from animals as there are paleoanthropologists. Evolutionists...

NEWS
The Return of the Dire Wolf?
There’s been much recent excitement about the birth of three dire wolf (Aenocyon dirus) puppies by a Dallas-based biotech company: Colossal Bioscience....

CREATION PODCAST
Cracks in the Layers: Lake Suigetsu and the Old Earth Illusion...
Welcome to the third episode in a series called “The Failures of Old Earth Creationism.” Many Christians attempt to fit old earth...

NEWS
Fish Fossil Vomit
A rather unsavory news story recently appeared regarding fossilized vomit. Although it’s hardly dinner table conversation, it nonetheless supports...

NEWS
Dino Footprints Down Under
Dinosaur trackways1 are once again making the news. Australia is the setting of a remarkable series of dinosaur tracks attributed to ornithischian...